Bartlett's Blog

Andrew Bartlett has been active in politics for over 20 years, including as a Queensland Senator from 1997-2008. This blog started in 2004 and reflects his own views, independent of any political party or organisation.

The Promised Land

Friday April 4th marked the fortieth anniversary of the assassination of Martin Luther King Jr. King’s legacy and impact is greatest by far in the USA, but he has become known around the world as a voice for human rights and non-violence. 

This piece by Joseph Palermo at The Huffington Post gives an interesting perspective on that legacy and on King’s final days.  It is interesting to speculate on how King would be portrayed today had he not been killed. As Palermo notes,

Contrary to mainstream belief today, while King was alive he was never widely heralded in the media as a “savior” or a “great leader.” He was just as often denounced as a “polarizing” figure and his work was often denigrated in racist terms. As was the case with Robert F. Kennedy, the love affair with MLK only took off long after he had become a kind of martyr.

I have no doubt that the world would have gained a great deal and would be a better place had Martin Luther King (and Robert Kennedy for that matter) not been killed.  But it is a shame that we so often need time and tragedy to be able to more clearly see or appreciate what it right before our eyes.

During the recent media firestorm in the US surrounding a few comments by Rev Jeremiah Wright, a preacher from Barack Obama’s church, that were deemed to be too unpatriotic, I saw a few people note that Martin Luther King had been also prepared at times to criticise his country in very strong terms. This interview with Michael Eric Dyson, the author of two books on King, gives the example where King preached in black churches saying that “America was founded on genocide, and a nation that is founded on genocide is destructive.” (Dyson also makes the point that ‘black churches’ would not have been established in the USA had black people not been prevented from worshipping in the same churches as the whites.)

King was regularly attacked in his time for being unpatriotic and un-American. I’m not suggesting Wright is a Martin Luther King figure, but rather that the depths of public debate and understanding can be greatly enhanced when we look beyond caricatures and soundbites to the full substance and context.

Barack Obama’s speech marking the fortieth anniversary is here. He spoke from Fort Wayne, Indiana. It was in Indianapolis, the capital of Indiana, that Robert Kennedy spoke to a crowd of thousands of black Americans on the night of King’s killing. As Palermo’s piece (and Obama’s speech) notes, this short heartfelt speech calls for understanding and campassion and wisdom, and is credited with ensuring that while many other cities in the USA erupted in violence, Indianapolis did not. A testament to the power of words and the huge impact, for good or ill, that people in positions of leadership can have at crucial moments.

ALSO: A reader pointed to this thoughtful piece at Religion Dispatches – King as Inspiration, Not Guide. Well worth a read.

Advertisement

4 Comments, Comment or Ping

  1. philip travers

    Words are either not powerful at all in Australia,or political rhetoric doesnt quite ring true.I have never really been given a chance to speak in public about the endless number of matters that also burn me out.I simply dont know,if these men werent assassinated the world would be any different.Rupert Murdoch seems to of met prominent American Democrats,so I will just go out of this topic backwards, as in life, as I am leading it,so Rupert never gets criticised ,for being like Winston Churchill!Except the printed word is in the aquarium,and the goldfish personalities,we all are,bar none,are waiting for Rupert to read the unforgetable words of history passing!?Clap louder goldfish! Its the only way we will get to hear him!Great Speech Rupert! Its like the story if Jesus returned to Earth would anyone recognise him!?

  2. togret

    Andrew, you may be interested in this http://religiondispatches.org/Gui/Content.aspx?Page=AR&Id=164 “King as Inspiration, Not Guide”

  3. Thanks for that Togret – an interesting and thoughtful piece. I’ll add it to the main post so a few more people might see it.

  1. Larvatus Prodeo - Apr 6th, 2008

Mini Posts

  • Radio chat on the election

    Every Monday morning during my radio show on community radio 4ZzZ FM, I chat with Peter Black, a constitutional lawyer, follower of social and political issues and obsessive user of social media. I don’t normally put links to those chats on this blog, but given that our talk this morning was all about the federal election, I thought it was worth putting a link to it on this occasion. You can have a listen to it by clicking on this link.

    (0)
  • Pre-election 'Debate' Farce

    Given I am now running as a Greens candidate, I suppose it is no surprise that I am indicating my agreement with a comment that Bob Brown made today.  But I would also say that it isn’t any secret that I haven’t agreed with every public comment that Bob has made, and I would agree with the following comment about the schoolyard level nonsense regarding another possible leaders debate even if it had been made by Steve Fielding:

    What we’re seeing now between the two leaders is an absolute farce and people everywhere are rolling their eyes at Tony Abbott and Julia Gillard not having the maturity to get together to agree to the series of debates which would have enlightened the electorate,
    It is a joke and a sad reflection on the optic and image driven nature of political media coverage in Australia. A couple of weeks ago, there was a three way debate at the National Press Club on important ICT issues such as internet filtering, broadband and wider communications policy.

    More... (6)
  • Mountains of Coal

    A couple of years ago I wrote a blog post about mountaintop mining in the USA. All mining has some impact, but the sheer destructiveness of this type of mining is astonishing – and that’s before you take into account the greenhouse impact of the coal. This article in the New York Times details the potential impact of a similar project in West Virginia. The significance of this proposal is that there is the possibility it may be stopped, or seriously curtailed, by the Obama administration, which would be a signal of a positive shift on this issue.

    (2)
  • Recent Interviews

    Following are links to a couple of recent radio interviews I’ve done, plus an online one

    More... (1)
  • Piece on The Drum about challenges ahead for the Greens

    As I noted in my previous post, this week’s Newspoll saw the Greens register 16% support – the highest that party has ever achieved, comparable to the Democrats best Newspoll result of 17% back in 1990. History suggests it is unlikely that this peak will be maintained right through to election day (or even the next Newspoll) but it is part of a continuing trend of solid Greens results. I’ve written a piece expanding on this, and how the party might approach the challenges ahead, at The Drum/Unleashed on the ABC’s site – which you can read by clicking on this link.

    (0)
  • Wild Rivers

    Contention over Queensland’s  Wild Rivers legislation has been bubbling along for quite a while now. Unfortunately, as with many issues which become polarised, each “side” is focused on defending their position, which has meant that some important underlying issues are not getting the attention they deserve. I’ve just had a piece on this topic published at The Drum on the ABC’s website.  It’s fairly long, so they published it in two parts – the first part is at this link and the second part is at this one.  I should emphasise that the article reflects my personal views, and is not a formal view of the Greens, nor of ANTaR Queensland, who I am also involved with.

    (18)
  • Listen in to Choose Mics

    Hip hop fans in Brisbane might be interested in tuning in to my radio show on 4ZZZ FM this Monday morning around 7:30am. I’ll be talking with the Gold Coast based duo Choose Mics, who are launching their debut full length album Beggars Can’t Be Choosers at the Step Inn in the Valley this coming Friday night as part of what will be a big night for fans of hip-hop/rap/urban sounds, with Brisbane’s The Optimen also launching their second album “The Out of Money Experience” as part of the same event. Even though there is a steady stream of musical offerings in Brisbane, a double album launch of this magnitude doesn’t come along every day of the week, so I’ll dedicate a half hour or so to exploring not just the words and sounds of Choose Mics, but getting a broader overview from them of the hip hop related scenes locally and nationally.

    More... (2)