Bartlett's Blog

Andrew Bartlett has been active in politics for over 20 years, including as a Queensland Senator from 1997-2008. This blog started in 2004 and reflects his own views, independent of any political party or organisation.

Vivan Solon’s Return Welcomed but New Terror Laws Will Still Impact on the Most Vulnerable

The Australian Democrats have welcomed the news that Vivian Alvarez Solon has arrived home in Sydney today four years after being wrongly deported but have raised concerns about such incidences reoccurring under the proposed anti-terror laws.

Spokesperson for Immigration Senator Bartlett said, "Ms Solons case is a perfect example of the gross injustice and incompetence that can occur where there are no adequate safeguards and accountability to protect individuals.

"Ms Solons is not an isolated case, it is merely one of many which have since been discovered.

The new terror laws which have been the subject of Senate Committee hearings this week have no adequate safeguards to protect innocent victims who may be inadvertently caught just by being at the wrong place at the wrong time.

"In the cases of Ms Solon and Ms Rau who fell through the cracks in part due to failings in our approach to mental illness, it is of great concern that that there are no provisions for mental health assistance at all for those who may be suffering from a mental illness and unable to fully appreciate the rigid constraints which are proposed in the new terror Bill.

"The prospect for an abuse of process under these archaic laws is high and has very real consequences for those who may be unintentionally targeted.

"Any law that provides extreme powers to government officers and Ministers without proper independent oversight and controls will inevitably lead to major injustices occurring.

"The Government’s determination to press ahead with legislation that undermines the rule of law and the basis of our liberal democracy shows they have not learnt any lessons from the travesty that was visited on Vivian Solon," Senator Bartlett concluded.

Advertisement

No Comments, Comment or Ping

Comments are closed.

Mini Posts

  • Question Time defined

    This line from David Marr is one of the best descriptions I’ve ever read of the farcical sound and fury which is Question Time in the House of Representatives:

    It’s a bit like an RSPCA pound: never free of the spectre of being put down, the dogs bark and howl to attract attention.

    (0)
  • Recent data on the climate

    For those interested in basic facts about temperature trends in Australia and globally over recent decades, there is a great post over at Lavartus Prodeo by Brian Banisch, who has been following the data and the various scientific reports on this issue for a long time. Very much worth having a read of for those who are just wanting some facts.

    (0)
  • Articles on Indian students, failed UN summits & refugees in our region

    Items on Indian students, refugees in our region and Copenhagen
    Below are links to some recent pieces I have written on other sites:
    - some impacts from the recent  http://asiancorrespondent.com/andrew-bartlett-blog/tragic-murder-puts-spotlight-back-on-safety-of-indians-in-australia murder of an Indian man living in Melbourne;
    - connections between http://blogs.crikey.com.au/thestump/2009/12/19/another-failed-summit/ the failures of a UN Summit on hunger and the Copenhagen climate change summit.
    - articles detailing some more mistreatment of refugees in our region here http://blogs.crikey.com.au/thestump/2009/12/29/more-refugee-torment-in-our-region/ and here http://asiancorrespondent.com/andrew-bartlett-blog/dangers-for-refugees-in-region-highlighted-by-forced-deportation-from-thailand
    Below are links to some recent pieces I have written on other sites

    More... (0)
  • Charities tapping into Christmas and social media

    Many not for profit and charity groups have got a lot smarter over the years in tapping into some of the large amounts of money that get spent over Christmas.  Christmas catalogues full of gifts for good cause groups have become widespread. In recent times, that has extended to bypassing a present all together, and giving someone a donation which actually goes direct to the good cause. This form of fundraising is now also tapping into social media, so much so that even my humble blog gets occasional requests to promote a cause from people who specifically target the avenues of social media to widen their reach. Here’s one example I recently received on behalf of World Vision. 

    More... (4)
  • The Hunger Summit

    I’ve posted a piece over at The Stump about the links between global hunger and climate change, and the unfortunate parallels between the less than successful climate change summit in Copenhagen and an even more dismal outcome at the recent Hunger Summit in Rome, which received far less attention.

    (0)
  • It was 20 years ago today.

    It was 20 years ago today.
    On 20 November 1989, the international Convention on the Rights of the Child (CROC) was formally adopted.  According http://www.hrw.org/en/news/2009/11/18/us-ratify-children-s-treaty?tr=y&auid=5614841 to Human Rights Watch, the Convention became “the most widely and rapidly ratified human rights treaty in history.  Twenty years on, only two countries have failed to ratify the Convention – Somalia and the USA.
    In the USA, Presidential action to ratify an international treaty requires the approval of the Senate.  I think this is a good mechanism and one Australia should adopt, even though it would undoubtedly be frustrating from time to time.  But regardless of the distractions of health care reform and climate change legislation, this is one action the USA’s President and Senate should get moving on.
    On 20 November 1989, the international Convention on the Rights of the Child (CROC) was formally adopted.  According to Human Rights Watch, the Convention became “the most widely and rapidly ratified human rights treaty in history.  Twenty years on, only two countries have failed to ratify the Convention – Somalia and the USA. Somalia currently has no recognised government, which makes it impossible for it to ratify the CROC.  In the USA, Presidential action to ratify an international treaty requires the approval of the Senate.  I think this is a good mechanism and one Australia should adopt, even though it would undoubtedly be frustrating from time to time.  But regardless of the distractions of health care reform and climate change legislation, this is one action the USA’s President and Senate should get moving on.

    (4)
  • Pieces published elsewhere

    Following are links to some items I’ve had published on other sites

    More... (0)